Parents, Ignore The Food Pyramid – It’s UNHEALTHY

Food Pyramid 2

The United States Department of Agriculture devised the Food Guide Pyramid in 1992, to help individuals make healthier decisions about what to eat and, consequently, to reduce the prevalence of lifestyle-related diseases.  The Pyramid presents complex carbohydrates as the basis of a healthy diet, suggesting that individuals should consume 6-11 servings daily.  It also suggests little to no consumption of fats and oils.  In 2003, a seminal work by Willett and Stampfer, published in Scientific American, revealed that the Food Guide Pyramid is largely flawed.  Their work, entitled “Rebuilding the Food Pyramid,” is based on extensive evidence that shows the failings of the original Food Guide Pyramid.  It argued that not all fats are bad for you – some fats can even reduce your chance of cardiovascular disease – and not all carbohydrates are good for you.  This paved the way for the new guidance system, “My Plate,” which officially replaced the Food Guide Pyramid in 2005.  My Plate presents the essential food groups as parts of a place setting, to clearly illustrate the ideal portion sizes of essential food groups required to make up a healthy meal.  Although the My Plate campaign has been running for over two years, the Food Guide Pyramid has shaped food-related decisions for over a decade.  Its messages about “healthy eating” were endorsed by governments, taught in schools, and were so well received that they continue to inform many food-related decisions made by parents and kids today.

Healthy decision-making in regards to food is also complicated by insinuations made by food labels and false assumptions made by shoppers when reading such phrases as “low fat” or “light.”  It is often assumed that “low fat” is the healthy opinion, when in fact the low fat option may have a slightly reduced fat content but a much higher sugar or salt content.  This is compounded when manufacturers market a product to be both low in fat and convenient.  This is often the case with breakfast bars, which are perceived to be healthy but are actually highly processed and high in sugar.  In consideration of this, we recommend that parents read the nutritional information of these products before they purchase, and consider the kilojoules in the product.  Parents should remember that an average daily intake of 8700 kilojoules is recommended.  Most importantly, parents should choose less processed options if possible, as less processed foods are generally more nutritious.

The recommendations made by the Food Guide Pyramid may be partially to blame for today’s childhood obesity crisis, as is the marketing of food perceived to be healthy, through phrases like “low fat.”  We would love to hear your thoughts on this issue!  Please share your thoughts in the comment section below.

About these ads

3 thoughts on “Parents, Ignore The Food Pyramid – It’s UNHEALTHY

  1. It doesn’t surprise me that the Pyramid devised in 1992 is being contested. I think after years of extended research and further studies, we’re only going to gain a better understanding of how accurate these things are. I think education is the most important tool for parents, because not everybody knows how to read nutritional information on packaging. This is something I only learnt to do quite well through PDHPE lessons at school. Parents need to be taught how to cut through all the promotional words and false promises on packaging and read the nutritional table accurately! Check out http://changeofheartau.wordpress.com/ for more information on ‘good’ fats. Yes, they do exist!

    • Thank you for your contribution @nkapovic ! Education certainly is a vital tool for parents, and it’s incredibly important that the information they receive is current. A significant amount of the information we believed to be true twenty years ago has be overturned by scientific research. You’re right, ‘good’ fats do exist, yet this seems like somewhat of a paradox to people, who would never expect ‘good’ and ‘fats’ to be in the same sentence! Parents need to reinforce the health education children are given in school – through subjects such as Personal Development, Health and Physical Education – however in order to do so, they must have access to simplified, credible and up-to-date information. Healthy Kids Sydney was established to provide parents with this. Thank you for linking me to your blog – you’ve got some fantastic and highly relevant content on there! Thanks once again for your input.

  2. This is incredibly interesting. Its good to know that continuous research is allowing people to stay informed about how to be healthy and what to eat. Your post is great because your getting a message out. So many people want to eat healthy they just don’t know how. If you would like some more information on the importance of breakfast and the debate behind the importance of protein, head to our blog! http://30adaydotoraway.wordpress.com/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s